The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is set to deliver its verdict in a seven-year-old case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar over allegations of genocide targeting the Rohingya people in Rakhine State.
Background: A Case Without Precedent
In the years since the 1948 Genocide Convention was adopted following World War II, dozens of individuals have been prosecuted for acts of genocide—such as those committed during conflicts in Rwanda and Bosnia. However, no state has ever been found guilty by an international court of committing genocide.
This case marks a significant departure from precedent. In November 2019, The Gambia filed a complaint at the ICJ arguing that all states are bound by the Genocide Convention, giving it legal standing to challenge Myanmar’s actions—even though Myanmar is not directly affected by the alleged violations.
Events in Rakhine State: A Pattern of Violence
In August and September 2017, hundreds of thousands of Rohingya fled across the border into Bangladesh following coordinated attacks on villages in Rakhine State. Multiple human rights organizations and a United Nations fact-finding mission have documented systematic violence—including mass killings, torture, rape, and arson—by Burmese military forces.
The BBC reports that these events were described as 'a military operation of exceptional brutality.' The UN's 2018 report found that Myanmar’s tactics during this period were 'grossly disproportionate to actual security threats' and recommended investigations into top military officials for possible crimes against humanity and genocide.
Myanmar’s Position: Denial and Defense
Myanmar authorities have consistently denied accusations of ethnic cleansing or genocide. They claim their actions in Rakhine State were responses to attacks by Rohingya militants, calling them 'clearance operations' aimed at restoring order.
The government has rejected the UN findings and maintains it did not intend to eliminate the Rohingya population. The case was brought under international law because Myanmar is not a signatory to the International Criminal Court (ICC), which would otherwise be the venue for such prosecutions.
Aung San Suu Kyi's Role and Criticism
In 2018, Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi personally led Myanmar’s legal defense of its actions before the ICJ in The Hague—an act that drew widespread criticism. Despite having limited influence over military operations in Rakhine State, her refusal to condemn those actions dismayed many who had previously admired her as a symbol of democratic resistance.
Since being deposed by a coup in 2021 and placed under arrest, the case has been defended by new officials appointed by the military regime.
The Legal Threshold: Proving Genocidal Intent
Under international law, proving genocide requires more than just acts of violence—it demands evidence that state actors acted with genocidal intent. The ICJ applies a high bar: judges require that only reasonable inference from available facts must be that the government intended to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group.
In Bosnia-Herzegovina’s 1993 case against Serbia, it took 14 years for the court to conclude that while some incidents—like the Srebrenica massacre—constituted genocide, there was insufficient proof that the Serbian state had genocidal intent.
Myanmar's legal team, led by lawyer Arsalan Suleman, argues that decades of systemic discrimination—including the 1982 citizenship law and subsequent policies restricting access to education, healthcare, livelihoods, and travel—are part of a broader pattern indicating genocidal intent. These measures, they assert, created an environment in which violence could be justified as 'clearance' operations with de facto elimination goals.
The Stakes: What Would Happen If The Gambia Wins?
If the ICJ rules in favor of The Gambia, Myanmar would face international condemnation for having committed genocide under the Genocide Convention. Such a ruling would represent one of the most significant legal developments in modern history—potentially setting precedent that states can be held accountable even when not directly affected by atrocities.
However, no final verdict has been issued yet. The court’s decision will depend on whether the weight of evidence—including historical context and state policies—is sufficient to establish genocidal intent beyond reasonable doubt.
The case remains legally complex, with both sides presenting arguments based on factual records and interpretations of law. As of now, there is no official judgment from the ICJ regarding this matter.