The New South Wales government has approved special legislation enabling the Mount Pleasant coal mine in the Hunter Valley to raise its annual extraction rate from 12.5 million tonnes to 16.5 million tonnes until 2032.
Government Justification
At the start of debate in the legislative council on Friday, Resources Minister Courtney Houssos described the bill as "a unique bill applying to unique circumstances," stating that it reflects "the gravity of the situation facing hundreds of workers and their families in the Hunter."
National Premier Chris Minns announced the measure shortly after, asserting it would save approximately 400 jobs ahead of Christmas. He has denied that the legislation circumvents a previous high court decision invalidating an earlier expansion proposal aimed at increasing output to 21 million tonnes by 2048.
Criticism from Experts and Opposition
The law has drawn significant criticism from legal experts, anti-corruption advocates, climate groups, crossbenchers, and civil liberties organisations.
In October, the High Court ruled in a 3-2 split judgment that the Independent Planning Commission (IPC) failed to adequately assess greenhouse gas emissions generated when coal is burned overseas — a key requirement under environmental planning laws. The ruling invalidated the prior approval for increased production.
Greens Climate Spokesperson Sue Higginson accused Minns of using the legislation as a political response to One Nation’s growing influence in the Hunter region, noting it was "very clear" that the decision stems from electoral concerns rather than economic or environmental necessity. She argued that a government assurance does not prevent setting dangerous precedents.
The Parliament's Legislation Review Committee has reported that this bill would effectively undermine ongoing legal proceedings before the Land and Environment Court and compromise procedural fairness by removing avenues for judicial review.
Job Guarantee and Oversight
The expansion is tied to a jobs guarantee covering more than 720 workers at MACH Energy’s Mount Pleasant mine. The data supporting this guarantee will be subject to an independent audit, according to official statements provided to the government.
Minns stated during a press conference on Wednesday that if the mine were to close, unemployment in Muswellbrook — where most of its workforce resides — could rise by 5%. He emphasized the community impact, speaking alongside union representatives from the Mining and Energy Union, which has welcomed the legislation.
Concerns Over Legal Clauses
The bill includes what critics have described as a "Henry VIII clause," allowing the resources minister to override state laws related to the Mount Pleasant development. While amended in the lower house to prevent use against investigations by the Independent Commission Against Corruption (Icac) or changes to production limits, legal experts remain concerned about potential misuse of executive power.
Barrister Geoffrey Watson warned this provision poses a "serious corruption risk" — particularly given its ability to bypass environmental and regulatory scrutiny without public accountability.
The Nature Conservation Council of NSW said it was "embarrassed into amending" its own coalmine legislation, while Greens maintain that the reforms do not sufficiently limit the minister’s authority under such clauses.
As of now, no independent verification has been conducted on whether the mine's expanded output will meet safety standards, emissions targets, or community impacts. The law remains in effect pending judicial review and further legal challenges.