●K13 NEWS / EDITION22/11/2026DIGITAL NEWSPAPERContact
K13 NEWS / WORLD
WORLD / K13 NEWS

Victorian Greens Seek Injunction Against How-To-Vote Cards Allegedly Mimicking Party Branding

The Victorian Greens are pursuing legal action to halt distribution by independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan of how-to-vote cards that allegedly replicate their branding and instruct voters to prefer the Liberal Party. The cards initially directed votes to place Liberals fourth; revised versions include different colors and a new banner, but critics say they still resemble Green Party materials.

Victorian Greens Seek Injunction Against How-To-Vote Cards Allegedly Mimicking Party Branding

The Victorian Greens have filed an urgent injunction application with the Supreme Court seeking to stop independent candidate Tosh-Jake Finnigan from distributing how-to-vote cards during the upcoming election prepoll.

Alleged Branding Mimicry

Finnigan’s campaign distributed cards on Wednesday morning using the minor party's color scheme, font, and triangle logo, featuring the banner 'Vote 1 Green Values'. The material instructed voters to give their first preference to Finnigan, followed by candidates from the Animal Justice Party and another independent, before placing the Liberal Party in fourth position — a configuration that would ultimately benefit the Liberal Party.

The Greens argue this constitutes deliberate mimicry of their branding. According to lawyer Adam McBeth at an initial hearing on Friday night, members of Finnigan’s team were seen wearing shirts with the exact shade of green used by genuine Greens volunteers and stood beside official Greens placards during prepoll events. He claimed there is no plausible explanation for why an independent candidate would choose such specific visual elements unless intending to mislead voters.

Response and Revisions

Finnigan responded by agreeing to cease distribution immediately after being contacted by Green party state director Martin Shield. Within hours, a revised card was produced featuring different colors and a new banner: 'Vote 1 Trans Greens Values'. The updated version includes a disclaimer stating: 'Due to legal threats from the Greens party, I confirm that I am not an endorsed Greens party candidate.'

The Greens maintain this revision does not resolve their concerns. On Friday afternoon, they lodged formal court papers in response to what they describe as a campaign designed to exploit public confusion about political affiliation.

Legal Proceedings and Court Response

A hearing on Friday night heard allegations of deliberate misrepresentation by Finnigan’s team during prepoll activities. Justice John Watson acknowledged that the original card appeared to be a 'pretty deliberate attempt' to pass off the independent candidate as affiliated with the Green Party but adjourned the matter until Saturday at 3 p.m., pending testimony from the Victorian Election Commission (VEC).

The VEC has since accepted the revised how-to-vote card and published it online, indicating its compliance with electoral guidelines. A final decision on whether an injunction will be granted is expected on Sunday morning.

Background: Candidate Profile

Tosh-Jake Finnigan became Victoria’s first openly transgender councillor in 2023 after winning election to Colac Otway Shire Council through a countback. They resigned from council in October 2024.

Finnigan previously worked as a field campaigner for Labor before becoming a whistleblower in what was known as the Red Shirts scandal — where taxpayer funds were allegedly used to pay electorate officers who campaigned for Labor. In 2022, they founded the Restore Democracy Sack Dan Andrews party and ran unsuccessfully for an upper house seat, securing only 1% of first preference votes.

Political Context

The Greens are attempting to reclaim the ultra-marginal Prahran seat lost by their previous candidate in February 2025 byelection, which ended with a margin of just 1.3%. The party fears that Labor’s open ticket in the area may deprive them of necessary preference votes during prepoll.

Finnigan's campaign Facebook page identifies themselves as 'Green Independent' but also includes attack ads targeting the Green Party. A source on the platform notes: 'We believe this is an effort to exploit public confusion and misrepresent political alignment.'

As of Friday evening, no official confirmation has been issued regarding whether the court will grant the injunction or allow further distribution under conditions. All information presented here is based solely on publicly available reports from The Guardian, with attribution given where relevant.

← FRONT PAGE