The Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM) has released a highly anticipated report reviewing how terrorism is defined in Australian law over the past 25 years. The watchdog says reference to religion in the legal framework contributes to discrimination and violence against religious minorities.
Religion Removed from Definition
In its findings, the INSLM recommends removing religion as a primary motivation in Australia’s definition of terrorism. According to the report, including religion in the legal definition gives accused individuals 'false credibility' by reinforcing their narrative that they are acting for a holy cause.
Jake Blight, head of the INSLM: "Having a law that requires proof that terrorists were advancing a ‘religious’ cause gives these terrorists false credibility and reinforces their narrative that they are doing holy work."
The current federal criminal code defines terrorism as an act intended to cause serious harm to people or property in order to advance a political, religious or ideological cause. The INSLM suggests redefining this to remove religion as a primary motivation and instead place it within a broader category of 'ideology'—a change aligned with international best practices.
International Context and Criticism
The report cites the United Nations special rapporteur’s 2025 findings, which recommended defining terrorist acts by political and ideological causes rather than including religious motives. It notes that references to religion have "discriminatory and stigmatizing effects" that outweigh any benefits from criminalising such actions.
In a submission to the INSLM, Australia's special envoy against Islamophobia, Aftab Malik, said retaining religion as a terrorism motivation creates a "climate of suspicion" around Muslim Australians and provides 'ammonition' for far-right extremist narratives.
Community Response
Eleven Muslim advocacy groups—including the Australian Muslim Advocacy Network—welcomed the report’s recommendations and urged the government to amend laws. In their joint statement: 'Every time someone in authority says that a motivation is ‘religious’, it uplifts ISIS, far-right and harmful media narratives all at once, by officially perpetuating the false premise that Islam encourages terrorism.'
Jewish Community Reaction
The Executive Council of Australian Jewry described the INSLM report as 'high-quality' but expressed concern over removing religion from the definition. Co-chief executive Peter Wertheim said: ‘The inclusion of ‘faith’ as a type of ideology does not solve the problem. Faith is not the same as religion and religion is more than an ideology.’
Wertheim added that it would be inappropriate for Australian law to determine which beliefs constitute authentic religious expression, noting even within any faith there are divergent views.
Punishment for Threats
The report also criticises current sentencing laws. Under existing legislation, making a credible terrorist threat can result in life imprisonment with a mandatory minimum sentence of six years. The INSLM says this punishment is 'disproportionate', 'unnecessarily complex' and out of line with international standards.
It recommends treating threats as a separate charge from actual acts—with a maximum penalty of no more than five years.
Rising Extremism Trends
Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) director-general Mike Burgess has warned about the rise of violent nationalism. In an October submission to a parliamentary inquiry into radicalisation, ASIO stated that approximately 65% of its counter-terrorism caseload relates to religiously-motivated extremism, while 35% involves ideologically-driven cases.
The INSLM also recommended raising the threshold for designating damage to property or electronic systems as terrorist acts and excluding advocacy, protest, dissent and industrial action from such classifications.
These recommendations reflect growing concerns over how legal definitions shape public perception and policy responses—particularly in relation to minority communities—and underscore the need for clarity between ideology, belief, and criminal conduct.