●K13 NEWS / EDITION20/11/2026DIGITAL NEWSPAPERContact
K13 NEWS / WORLD
WORLD / K13 NEWS

US Warns Supplying Nuclear Submarines to Australia Would Diminish Its Own Fleet for Many Years

A new Congressional Budget Office (CBO) report warns that transferring nuclear-powered submarines to Australia would significantly reduce U.S. Navy capabilities for years. The analysis questions whether Australian-flagged vessels could be compelled into service during a conflict with China and highlights delays in submarine production within the United States.

US Warns Supplying Nuclear Submarines to Australia Would Diminish Its Own Fleet for Many Years

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has released an assessment raising concerns about how supplying Virginia-class nuclear-powered attack submarines to Australia under the Aukus agreement might impact the United States' own naval fleet.

U.S. Submarine Production Capacity

CBO findings indicate that current U.S. shipyard output is insufficient to meet demand, producing only one Virginia-class submarine per year—falling far short of the rate needed for domestic operations alone. To maintain sufficient numbers for its own navy, the U.S. would need to increase production from 1.13 to two submarines annually; to also supply Australia, it would require a total build rate of 2.33 vessels per year.

The report notes that construction timelines have expanded dramatically: in the 2000s, building a Virginia-class submarine took five to six years on average. Today, under current schedules, the process takes between ten and eleven years—a significant slowdown over two decades.

Impact on U.S. Fleet Readiness

The CBO states explicitly that selling any Virginia-class submarine to Australia would reduce the number of attack submarines available for U.S. Navy operations 'for many years.' The analysis does not factor Aukus into its shipbuilding forecasts at all; it only includes a footnote noting that transfers to Australia have been excluded from planning.

This reduction raises questions about whether such a transfer could compromise U.S. strategic deterrence in the Indo-Pacific region—particularly amid rising tensions with China over Taiwan and maritime claims in the South China Sea.

Operational Autonomy and Conflict Response

The report asks: Would China be less deterred if the United States reduced its undersea capabilities by supplying submarines to Australia?

In theory, Australian submarines based in the Western Pacific might respond more quickly to regional crises than those operating within U.S. waters. However, the CBO emphasizes that Australia would retain full control of any transferred vessels—and there is no guarantee they could or would participate in a conflict involving the United States.

Australia’s defence minister, Richard Marles, has previously stated that future Australian submarines will operate 'under the complete control of the Australian government of the day' and that no commitments are made regarding their deployment during a U.S.-China confrontation.

Legal and Political Framework

The Aukus agreement includes provisions allowing the U.S. to refuse transferring any submarine without penalty—provided it does not degrade undersea capabilities. The transfer must be authorized by the president only if losing that vessel from U.S. service won’t impair overall U.S. naval readiness.

Critics argue there is little likelihood the United States will deliver on its commitment, with former foreign affairs minister Bob Carr stating both nations 'are living a lie' in promoting the deal as viable. He noted that such expectations are now widely seen in Washington and Canberra as unrealistic.

Alternative Proposals

The U.S. Congressional Research Service has explored an alternative model: retaining all Virginia-class submarines under American command but operating them out of Australian bases during crises or conflicts—such as those involving Taiwan or South China Sea disputes.

This approach would allow for immediate deployment by U.S.-commanded vessels while maintaining operational continuity. In contrast, if Australia controls its own submarines, they could not be ordered into service without political decisions made independently—and no assurance exists about their readiness or participation in a conflict.

Despite these concerns and skepticism from experts and former officials, the Aukus agreement continues to enjoy bipartisan support across both countries. Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth affirmed at a meeting with Marles in September that the alliance remains 'unimpeded' and committed to strengthening deterrence in the Pacific region.

← FRONT PAGE