●K13 NEWS / EDITION21/11/2026DIGITAL NEWSPAPERContact
K13 NEWS / TECHNOLOGY
TECHNOLOGY / K13 NEWS

Can AI Really Help Spot Black Friday Deals? A Test Shows Mixed Results

A test of four popular AI tools found inconsistent and often inaccurate price information during a search for a 55-inch TV. While some models offered plausible options, many links led to dead ends or outdated data. Experts warn that AI-generated shopping suggestions may reflect stale pricing rather than current market realities.

Can AI Really Help Spot Black Friday Deals? A Test Shows Mixed Results

Black Friday has long been known as a time when retailers promise deep discounts — but the sheer volume of offers can make it hard to find genuine value.

We tested four widely used generative AI tools — ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Alexa — to see if they could help identify real deals on a new 55-inch television. The goal was simple: save money by using an AI tool to filter through hundreds of online listings.

ChatGPT’s Recommendations

The most detailed response came from ChatGPT, which listed several TVs across different platforms. Its top pick was a Hisense TV on Joybuy (China), priced at £499 down from £649. However, when we followed the link, both retailers reported that the product had been removed from their site.

A second option — another 55-inch TCL-branded model — showed price ranges for a smaller size (50 inches) between £379 and £814, suggesting inconsistent data presentation. A third recommendation repeated the same Hisense TV but at full price (£649) through John Lewis and Richer Sounds, labeled as the "best safer purchase" due to longer warranties. Again, clicking these links resulted in no available products.

ChatGPT ended with an ad-marked LG OLED TV priced at £1,100, which was not listed on any retailer’s current site.

Claude: Minimal Detail, Limited Credibility

Claude produced a brief response compared to other models. It recommended two TCL TVs — identical to those suggested by ChatGPT — but based its choices largely on online reviews that were not independently verified or updated.

When we clicked the links, both redirected to dead pages on Richer Sounds’ website. Claude also mentioned two Samsung TVs and advised against purchasing them, calling one "over budget" and "not clearly better than the TCLs." The reason for including these options remains unclear in the output.

Gemini: A Table with No Links

Gemini generated a table comparing four TV models, including prices for one TCL model at £649 (correct), which was sold out at one retailer. For another TCL option, it claimed availability through Argos (£539) and Currys (£60 more). We verified that Argos' price is accurate but Currys’ listed price exceeds what was stated.

It also excluded two Samsung TVs due to lower screen specifications — suggesting technical criteria were applied, though no explanation of how these thresholds were defined was provided.

Alexa: Amazon-Only Results

Alexa returned four TV options, with its top pick being a Samsung model priced at £616 (down from £749), based on picture quality and customer ratings. However, Alexa only searches within Amazon’s own inventory. Its response acknowledged this limitation by advising users to check other retailers for better deals or longer guarantees.

The fourth option listed was a 50-inch Sony TV, which contradicts the original search request — raising questions about why it was included in the results.

Why AI Tools Fall Short

Despite growing interest, few UK consumers use AI tools when shopping. A YouGov survey of 19 countries found that the UK ranked second-last in people who reported using AI to help with purchases. Of those planning Black Friday shopping, 36% said they would not use any AI tool at all.

Tech journalist Alex Hughes tested ChatGPT’s "agentic" mode last year and found success: he used a multi-step process guided by AI to locate a TV during sales. He noted it took about 20 minutes and required minimal input — but ultimately did not purchase the device. Later, he bought one from a physical store for less than what was suggested online.

Experts Warn of Stale Data

Naureen Mohammed, who advises businesses on how products appear in search results, explained that many retailers fail to update prices as demand rises before Black Friday. As a result, chatbots often serve outdated deals — showing last year’s pricing instead of current offers.

"I suspect the whole model for advertising is going to start influencing AI recommendations," she said. "When people hunt for bargains, they see old prices presented as new ones."

In short: AI tools can generate plausible suggestions and offer structured comparisons — but their outputs are not reliable indicators of real-time availability or actual savings. The data behind them may be stale, links may lead nowhere, and product details remain inconsistent across platforms.

No tool tested here provided verified, actionable results that matched a true Black Friday deal with available inventory at competitive price points. All responses were based on inputs from retailers whose listings had changed or been removed by the time we attempted to verify them.

← FRONT PAGE