The Trump Department of Justice filed a legal action before the midterm elections aiming to prevent the certification of the U.S. Senate seat in Alaska if Democrat Mary Peltola won the election.
Background: Two Candidates Named Dan Sullivan
The lawsuit was based on allegations that voters might have been confused by two candidates sharing the same name—Republican Senator Dan Sullivan and another candidate named Daniel Sullivan—who both ran for the same office.
In a filing released Thursday, the administration requested that a federal appeals court declare its case moot—the legal term meaning it no longer has active relevance because the race had already concluded and results were certified.
The Alaska Supreme Court previously ruled that the second candidacy of Daniel Sullivan was legally valid and could appear on the ballot. The state’s election system used ranked-choice voting to determine outcomes in races where no single candidate received over 50% of votes cast.
Vote Count and Controversy
Mary Peltola won the Senate seat with 50.13% of the vote, exceeding all other candidates including both Dan Sullivan and another Daniel Sullivan. According to reports from The Guardian, the second Sullivan was reportedly recruited by Democratic operatives as a 'decoy' to siphon support away from the incumbent Republican senator.
Peltola has denied any involvement in encouraging or supporting this campaign strategy. She is Yup’ik and will become one of two Native American women elected to serve in the U.S. Senate—joining Minnesota’s Peggy Flanagan, who is Ojibwe and a member of the White Earth Band.
Additional Ballot Controversy
In addition to the Dan Sullivan cases, another candidate named Eric Hafner appeared on the ballot despite having no ties to Alaska. He was allowed to run as a Democrat against the state party's official nominee, despite being incarcerated at the time in federal prison in New York. Hafner received 22,715 votes.
If all of his ballots had been cast for Hill—a Democratic-endorsed candidate—Hill would have defeated Begich in that race. The inclusion of such an unconnected individual raises questions about the integrity and oversight of the election process under ranked-choice voting rules.
Administration’s Position
The administration argued that voter confusion could occur due to identical names on the ballot. However, it did not explain how a formal investigation into this issue could be conducted given the secrecy of ballot casting or the absence of any evidence suggesting widespread confusion among voters.
No official findings were presented to support claims of electoral misconduct or voter misdirection. As of now, no independent audit has been released to verify whether the presence of multiple candidates with similar names affected actual vote outcomes.