The African National Congress (ANC) has faced a sharp decline in influence across South Africa's urban centers after the recent municipal elections, where it won only one provincial majority—Limpopo—and secured top vote counts in just two cities out of eight compared to six in 2021.
National Vote Share and Local Decline
While the ANC received 31% of national votes—a drop from its previous 46%—it still holds an overall plurality. However, this support is unevenly distributed: in Gauteng province, which includes Johannesburg and Pretoria, the pro-business Democratic Alliance (DA) captured the most votes in both major cities as well as Ekurhuleni, a key economic region within the province.
The party retained control over Cape Town and secured the highest vote share in Nelson Mandela Bay, where Gqeberha (Port Elizabeth) is located. The left-leaning uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party, led by former President Jacob Zuma, came third nationally with 10%, repeating its performance from the 2024 national election when it became official opposition after joining a coalition government with the DA.
ANC’s Shift Toward Smaller Parties
In KwaZulu-Natal—home to Durban—the MK Party emerged as the largest single entity with 34% of votes, though it remains dependent on forming coalitions for governance. Meanwhile, ActionSA, which gained 17% in Gauteng and positioned itself as a potential kingmaker, is seen as an alternative partner by ANC leaders seeking local alliances beyond the DA.
A party insider cited by Daily Maverick stated that at an internal meeting, 'a nationwide agreement to work with the DA at municipal level was overwhelmingly rejected' by top ANC officials. This suggests growing resistance within the party toward replicating its national power-sharing arrangement with the DA at city levels.
DA’s Position and Political Tensions
The DA has not formally announced any new arrangements but appears poised to assume opposition roles—particularly in Gauteng—where it currently leads vote counts. ActionSA is unlikely to cooperate with the DA due to disagreements over mayoral candidates for Johannesburg and Pretoria.
Political analyst Andre Duvenhage told BBC that 'a lot of asymmetrical coalitions' could emerge, meaning parties might govern jointly in some areas while remaining in opposition elsewhere. Sandile Swana cautioned that any party attempting to exit the Government of National Unity (GNU) coalition would likely face significant setbacks, calling such moves 'shooting oneself in the foot'.
Criticism Over Service Delivery
The ANC’s declining support has been widely attributed to persistent corruption allegations and public distrust regarding its ability to deliver basic services like electricity, water supply, and waste management.
While critics credit the DA with more effective municipal governance under its control, others argue it has neglected poorer townships and marginalized communities. Nevertheless, past experiences show little improvement: half of South Africa's cities have operated through power-sharing coalitions since 2016, many of which have collapsed or functioned poorly due to instability during transitions between agreements.
In Gauteng, where multiple coalition arrangements have failed to ensure consistent service delivery, residents continue to face disruptions in essential infrastructure—highlighting ongoing challenges for any new local government model.